By Renae
Merle Washington Post Staff Writer Wednesday, January 22, 2003; Page
A10
The two government contractors ambushed in Kuwait yesterday are
part of the growing army of civilians who accompany troops into sometimes
hostile territory.
In military hot spots around the world, civilians are performing
duties once reserved for military personnel -- building barracks, running
kitchens, maintaining tanks and jets, and even helping to plan
strategy.
"The Army couldn't go to war without them," said Deborah Avant,
an associate professor of political science at George Washington
University.
The two Americans attacked near Camp Doha in Kuwait are employees
of Tapestry Solutions Inc., a San Diego information technology firm that
is helping the military install software that coordinates operations.
Michael Rene Pouliot, co-founder of the firm, was killed, and David
Caraway, a senior software engineer, was wounded. Caraway is listed as
being in critical condition but is expected to recover, according to the
company.
During the Persian Gulf War, some units had one contractor for 50
military personnel while others had one for every 25, according to
research by Peter W. Singer, a fellow at the Brookings Institution. In the
Balkans, there was one contractor per 10 soldiers, Singer said. The ratio
of contractors to combatants could increase even more if the United States
goes to war in Iraq, he said.
The Defense Department does not keep track of the number of
contractors overseas but recognizes that such assignments are part of a
growing trend, said spokesman Glenn Flood. The General Accounting Office
reported that 10 percent of the $13.8 billion spent on Balkans operations
from 1995 through March 2000 went to private companies.
In 1991, Reston-based DynCorp had 650 personnel in the Middle East
supporting the Desert Shield-Desert Storm operations, according to company
officials. DynCorp is among the largest companies in the sector, along
with Alexandria-based MPRI Inc., which is operated by retired senior
military officers, and Kellogg Brown & Root, a subsidiary of
Halliburton Co.
"In modern warfare, the front line is not well defined, so
knowing when contractor personnel is at risk is harder to predict," said
Loren B. Thompson, chief operating officer of the Lexington Institute, an
Arlington-based think tank. "The military is now so dependent on the
private sector for logistics and support, I am not sure it could function
without contractors."
Private-sector companies have played a part in military
operations overseas for decades, but their numbers grew in the 1990s. And
as the military deploys complex weapons systems faster, contractors go
overseas to provide training that there wasn't time for in the United
States.
"Starting after '91, you had the combination of the military
being forced to downsize and this real push to privatize anything and
everything," said Singer of the Brookings Institution. "The problem is
that it's been fairly random."
Along with contracting out logistical or support tasks such as
feeding military personnel or mowing lawns, the military has also handed
over to companies some duties that straddle the line between contractor
and soldier, such as maintaining tactical systems and drone aircraft,
Singer said.
There are essentially no rules for how contractors should behave
in a war zone, and there is no effort within the industry to create any,
according to industry analysts. The contractors don't have to follow the
military codes of conduct. Contractors are usually not allowed to carry
weapons but could be expected to pick up arms if they are attacked,
industry officials said.
Some DynCorp employees working for the Air Force in the Balkans
in 2001 were implicated in trafficking in women for sex. They were also
accused of consorting with underage girls and patronizing brothels.
That same year, private contractors piloting a CIA plane on a
drug interdiction flight over Peru mistakenly identified a missionary
plane as belonging to drug smugglers. The misidentified plane was shot
down, killing an American missionary and her infant, Avant said.
A DynCorp pilot was killed last January when the Colombian
military destroyed a U.S. government helicopter to keep it from falling
into the hands of leftist guerrillas. In 1992, three DynCorp employees
were killed when their helicopter crashed during U.S. anti-drug operations
in Peru.
In addition to worrying about the behavior and safety of
contractors, the military needs to worry about their reliability, said
Singer. Nothing prevents a contractor who is, for example, purifying water
for soldiers, or doing other critical tasks, from abandoning his station,
he noted.
"A potential fear is that the contractors will say 'This is a lot
dicier than I thought' and bolt," Singer said. "They may have thought they
were going to Kuwait and would be safe, but they're entering a war zone."
Some of those issues are raising concern in Congress.
"If they are American citizens or hired by us, private
contractors are targets for terrorists, as are U.S. government employees,"
Sen. Patrick J. Leahy (D-Vt.), the ranking Democrat on the Senate
Appropriations subcommittee on foreign operations, said in a written
statement. "But as contractors they do not always receive the same amount
of protection. The higher risks they face should be troubling to everyone,
and we need to continually review whether there is more we can do to
protect these people."
Officials of DynCorp and Kellogg Brown & Root declined to comment
on the safety precautions taken by their employees when assisting the
military overseas, saying it could put them in further danger.
"No one at MPRI carries a gun. We're dependent on who we're
working for," an MPRI official said.
A spokesman for Tapestry said all employees dispatched overseas
undergo a week of security training at Fort Benning in Georgia.
"Tapestry Solutions will continue its overseas operations and
persevere though this horrible tragedy," Mark Young, the company's vice
president, said in a statement. "The safety of our employees throughout
the world will continue to be paramount, and we will not be intimidated by
this act of violence."